Skip to main content

Tuscarawas Agency Company is a multi-generational independent agency.

About Our Agency - Happy Mother and Daughter Pay for Eggs at a Farmer's Market

Home » About Our Agency

In order to protect the things that are most important to you, we emphasize solid insurance coverage and service.

We are proud to be forged through a rich history.

We pride ourselves on being rooted in the history of the communities in which we operate as an independent insurance agency with three locations throughout Ohio. In fact—our agency’s founder, William W. Weisgarber, believed that establishing a successful business through personal relationships with each customer should always be our first priority. Decades later, we still hold true to our valued roots of solid insurance coverage, trusted relationships, and service.

The birth of the next generation.

In April 2020, Zach Mottice purchased The Tuscarawas Insurance Agency from Bill Weisgarber. Having been an Insurance Agent for over a decade, Zach had a vision of owning his own Independent Insurance Agency. Zach worked as an agent at Tuscarawas Insurance, adding tremendously to its growth and retention over the years. His success led to the opportunity to take ownership of the agency as Bill was ready to hand over the reigns to the next generation of independent agents.

We’re growing into our newest chapter.

Having been deeply rooted in the Sugarcreek area and Garaway Local School District as a coach, friend, and mentor to many; Zach sought additional opportunities to continue the expansion of Tuscarawas Insurance Agency into the area. In January 2021, Zach purchased Swiss Village Insurance Agency from Tonya Detorio. This new partnership allowed Tuscarawas Insurance Agency to continue a long history of outstanding customer service for our clients. With this new chapter, we are confident we will be able to give you even better customer service and greater company options as well as the best coverage and pricing for all of your insurance needs.

We’re a business that puts our community first.

We are proud to work alongside other independent insurance agencies in our area to raise money for Westfield’s Legacy of Caring program. It is our belief that non-profit organizations, and insurance protection, play a crucial role in stabilizing families, businesses, and communities in times of crisis. Our commitment to our community provides a greater impact on long-term outcomes for our future, and for the needs of our neighbors.

The Independent Agency Advantage

Here’s what makes our insurance agency different.

Personalized Solutions

Get the power of choice with insurance that’s designed for your unique needs.

Knowledgeable Service

We’ll be there for you with reliable service and support to help you make informed decisions.

Trusted Relationships

You can rely on us to simplify the insurance process and advise you on your insurance.

Find Your Coverage

We’re here to help you explore your coverage options.

Request Quote

Read Tuscarawas Agency Company‘s Reviews

Read Our Reviews

Contact Tuscarawas Agency Company

Our Partnerships

Three Convenient Locations to Serve You

Tuscarawas Agency Company is located in New Philadelphia, OH, Sugarcreek, OH, Strasburg, OH. We are also licensed in Ohio and Florida.

Contact Us

Learn More About Each Location’s History

New Philadelphia, OH

Sugarcreek, OH

Strasburg, OH

Our Mission

Through our three locations, Tuscarawas Agency Company strives to provide you with outstanding customer service, quality coverage, and affordable pricing for your insurance needs.




Years in Business


Industries Served
Insurance Designed for Your Needs

Contact Our Team

We specialize in a variety of coverage options to meet your unique insurance needs.

Meet Our Team

Let’s Get Started

  1. Step 1Fill out the form.
  2. Step 2Review your options with us.
  3. Step 3Get the coverage you need.

Request an Insurance Quote

"*" indicates required fields

Please do not include sensitive, private information in this area.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Don’t like forms? Contact us at 330-602-2700 or email us.